SpiraTest Vs. TestRail

Choosing a Test Case Management tool is not a simple task. The truth is that there is not one tool that is objectively better. You should choose the tool that fits your own QA process best. So, the key is knowing what features you need, and then finding out which of solutions available matches your requirements.

SpiraTest Vs. TestRail At a Glance

Both SpiraTest and TestRail have basic test case management capabilities.

The main difference between these two platforms is that TestRail relies on 3rd party integrations for requirements and issues management as it doesn’t have these modules at all while SpiraTest has Requirements and Issues management modules.

Both tools do not have compliance and security certifications such as SOC2 Type2, which might be an issue for enterprise organizations.

SpiraTest My Page

SpiraTest My Page

SpiraTest release

SpiraTest release

TestRail Release

TestRail Release

TestRail Version

TestRail Version

How SpiraTest and TestRail Stack Up

The comparison below reviews the main features to take into account when considering which one of the two will best fit your QA needs.

If you want better comparison between the tools you are checking, and the features available in other tools, please click below.

Button description
SpiraTest TestRail
See who is scored higher than SpiraTest See who is scored higher than TestRail
Requirement and User Stories Management
Support for hierarchical requirements
Test case management
Add attachments to each test step
Clone Tests between projects
Batch operations (cloning, editing, deletion)
Reusable test repositories
Exploratory Testing module (session based testing)
Test Sets and Execution Management
Audit history of runs and results
Edit tests during runs
Report issues/bugs from tests and auto-populate tests to reproduce
Assignment of Cycles and Tests to testers
Parameterization of Test Cases and Sets
Batch operations (cloning, editing, deletion)
Reuse tests from repository for any test set run
Test Set Permutations N/A
Issue management
Independent issue management module
Ability to detect and prevent duplicate issues
Ability to report issues directly from emails
Batch editing
Integrations
Integration with 3rd party Bug Tracking systems
Integration with Test Automation Tools
Integration with Source Control systems
Zapier
API
Slack integration
Webhooks
Customization
Hierarchical filters to organize information (e.g. Test Tree, Bug categories, Requirement types)
Custom Workflow
Custom fields and filters
Permissions & personalized mail notifications
Reporting
Customizable Dashboards graphs, reports and metrics
Scheduled reports
Additional features
Import & Export all data
Search (ability to add criteria)
External dashboard and embedding graphs
Cloud or Installed Both Both
Task Board
Security and certifications
Soc 2
ISO 27001
Service and Support
Service and Support
Compare SpiraTest to PractiTest Compare TestRail to PractiTest
G2 badges

Pros & Cons

Pros:

  • Part of a complete development toolset
  • Concurrent licenses available
  • Release module
  • Mobile responsive
  • Cloud and server solutions

Cons:

  • Rely on Amazon security compliance
  • Many features are available only for more costly tools or at an extra charge
  • Jira panel doesn’t give visibility into testing information for Jira users
  • No Faceted search
  • Exploratory test behaves almost the same as scripted test
  • No Kanban board

Pros:

  • A part of a fuller applications portfolio
  • Milestones modules to manage releases
  • Relatively cheaper
  • Has both Cloud and Server solutions
  • Easy intuitive use

Cons:

  • No requirements and issues modules
  • Jira Integration is less robust because issues can not be viewed and managed in TestRail
  • Only API for automation integration
  • Lack of support
  • Restrictive reporting capabilities
  • Rely on Amazon security compliance

Pricing

  • 10 cloud concurrent users per year - $350 billed monthly / $3,790 billed annually
  • 20 cloud concurrent users per year - $678 billed monthly / $7,322 billed annually

Annually

  • Professional - $33 per user/month
  • Enterprise - $64 per user/month

Monthly

  • Professional - $36 per user/month (No customizable email notification, no onboarding and training sessions and no test parameterization)

Didn’t find what you are looking for?

Try this dynamic comparison tool